The vast majority of personal injury claims are settled outside the courtroom, but that doesn’t mean all cases end this way. We’ll do our best to deliver a positive result for your case, but sometimes that simply isn’t possible through settlement negotiations. Sometimes, the only right move to get our client the money they deserve is by making our voice heard in the courtroom. Below, we take a closer look at some signs that you should skip the settlement and pursue your case in front of a judge.
Signs That You Shouldn’t Settle Your Injury Case
If you’re dealing with any of these issues during the course of your injury case, consider them signs that a settlement agreement may not be the best path forward.
Insurance Disputes Or Denies Claim – If the insurance company is disputing your claim or denying coverage, there’s a good chance that you’ll need to make your case in front of a judge if you want to earn a fair compensation package. You can appeal or re-file your claim with the insurance company, but if they are denying coverage, you’ll have to take your case to a judge if you want to win an award.
Lowball Settlements – We always tell clients not to expect a great offer out of the gates, but if the settlement offer is well below where you value your claim, and an evidence-based counteroffer isn’t getting an offer near where you’d accept, you’ll likely need to make your case before a judge if you want to earn compensation.
Talks Break Down – We assist many clients with the mediation or arbitration process as a way of trying to find an amicable solution before going to court, but sometimes these talks break down too. If it seems like the other side isn’t willing to concede on some of your points, or it seems like they are intentionally drawing the process out in order to put additional pressure on your side, it may be time to tell them that you’re content handling the matter in court.
Your Attorney Considers It Your Best Route – Any attorney can get a mild settlement for their client and push them out the door, but you deserve better than that. We take the time to review every facet of your case to come up with a fair and generous settlement proposal as well as a plan to take the matter in front of a judge if we don’t receive fair terms from the other side. If your attorney truly believes your best option or the right option is to explain your case to a judge, perhaps it’s best to trust their judgment. Insurance companies rely on your inexperience, so lean on industry expertise and trust their judgement.
Settlements are the right option in many instances, but we won’t back down from taking your case before a judge. Let us lay out all your options, go over the best and worst case scenarios for your case and determine the right path forward for you and your family. Even if you’re unsure if you have a valid claim, we want to hear from you. Pick up the phone and reach out to Dean and the team at Margolis Law Firm today. Give us a call at (952) 230-2700.
- Protect Your Future With A Workers’ Compensation Claim - November 12, 2026
- No Settlement Here – Signs Your Injury Claim Should Head To Litigation - November 6, 2026
- My Company Is Pressuring Me To Return To Work After My Injury - October 29, 2026